Internal And Workplace Investigations - Frequently Asked Questions

What is a workplace investigation?
A workplace investigation is a formal inquiry conducted by an organization to determine whether laws, policies, or workplace standards have been violated and what corrective action, if any, is required.

What is an internal investigation?
An internal investigation is a structured fact-finding process initiated after allegations of misconduct, harassment, discrimination, theft, safety violations, or policy violations arise within the organization.

Why are workplace investigations important?
Proper investigations:

• Protect employees
• Reduce legal exposure
• Demonstrate compliance with federal and state laws
• Prevent misconduct patterns
• Strengthen organizational trust

When is an employer legally required to investigate?
Employers generally must investigate when they become aware of:

• Harassment or discrimination complaints
• Workplace violence allegations
• Safety violations
• Retaliation claims
• Certain FMLA or leave abuse allegations

What happens if an employer fails to investigate properly?
Failure to conduct a timely and thorough investigation can result in:

• EEOC claims
• Lawsuits
• Government penalties
• Reputational damage

What types of issues typically require an investigation?
Common triggers include:

• Sexual harassment
• Workplace discrimination
• Bullying or hostile work environment
• Theft or fraud
• FMLA abuse
• Workplace violence
• Safety violations

Should every complaint result in a full investigation?
Not always. HR must first assess whether the allegation warrants formal investigation or informal resolution.

Can anonymous complaints require investigation?
Yes. Anonymous complaints must be evaluated carefully and often still require action.

Do verbal complaints require investigation?
Yes. Complaints do not need to be written to trigger investigative obligations.

Must investigations be conducted immediately?
Investigations should begin promptly to minimize liability and preserve evidence.

What are the first steps in conducting a workplace investigation?
Key initial steps include:

• Assessing the complaint
• Preserving evidence
• Determining scope
• Assigning an impartial investigator

How is the scope of an investigation defined?
The scope should clearly define:

• Allegations
• Relevant timeframes
• Involved individuals
• Applicable policies

What evidence should be gathered?
Investigators may gather:

• Emails
• Personnel records
• Text messages
• Surveillance footage
• Witness statements
• Physical evidence

What is chain of custody?
Chain of custody refers to properly documenting and preserving evidence to maintain its integrity.

How are witness interviews conducted properly?
Interviews should be:

• Structured
• Neutral
• Confidential
• Documented carefully

How do investigators assess credibility?
Credibility assessments consider:

• Consistency
• Corroboration
• Demeanor
• Motive
• Documentation

Should interviews be recorded?
Policies vary. Documentation is required, but recording may raise legal or state law concerns.

How detailed should investigation notes be?
Notes should be factual, objective, and thorough enough to withstand legal scrutiny.

Is confidentiality guaranteed?
Confidentiality should be maintained to the greatest extent possible, but absolute confidentiality cannot always be promised.

How is the investigation concluded?
Investigators prepare a written findings report outlining:

• Allegations
• Evidence reviewed
• Findings
• Policy violations
• Recommended action

What laws commonly trigger investigation requirements?
Common laws include:

• Title VII (Civil Rights Act)
• ADA
• ADEA
• FMLA
• OSHA
• State harassment laws

Does FMLA abuse require investigation?
Yes. While many HR professionals are wary of doing so, suspected abuse should be investigated carefully and consistently, with the options for abusers including disciplinary actions that include termination.

When should outside counsel be involved?
Legal counsel may be appropriate when:

• Senior leadership is implicated
• Litigation is likely
• Criminal activity is suspected

Can poor investigations create liability?
Yes. Biased, incomplete, or delayed investigations often increase liability exposure.

Should HR serve as the investigator?
Often yes - but only if properly trained and impartial.

How does investigations training reduce risk?
Training ensures:

• Legal compliance
• Consistent processes
• Defensible documentation
• Reduced retaliation claims

What are the biggest investigation pitfalls?
Common mistakes include:

• Failing to act promptly
• Showing bias
• Poor documentation
• Ignoring retaliation risks

What is retaliation risk?
Retaliation occurs when an employee suffers adverse action after filing a complaint or participating in an investigation.

How should interim measures be handled?
Temporary steps (schedule changes, leave, reporting adjustments) may be necessary to protect employees during investigation.

When should law enforcement be involved?
In cases involving:

• Workplace violence
• Criminal conduct
• Serious threats

What makes an investigation defensible?
A defensible investigation is:

• Timely
• Impartial
• Well-documented
• Legally compliant
• Consistent with policy

How can investigations avoid disrupting the workplace?
Proper planning, confidentiality controls, and structured interviews reduce operational disruption.

Should accused employees be informed immediately?
Generally yes - once preliminary fact-gathering is complete.

How do you protect both accuser and accused?
By:

• Maintaining neutrality
• Avoiding assumptions
• Limiting information access
  Preventing retaliation

Can mediation replace investigation?
Sometimes - but only when the issue does not involve serious legal violations.

What training options are available?
Programs include:

• Internal Investigations Certificate Program
• Advanced Internal Investigations Certificate Program
• HR Investigations 101
• FMLA Abuse Investigation Training
  Virtual and in-person seminars

What is covered in the Internal Investigations Certificate Program?
Participants learn:

• Legal frameworks
• Interview techniques
• Evidence handling
• Documentation standards
  Retaliation safeguards

What is the difference between basic and advanced programs?
Advanced programs address:

• Complex cases
• Executive-level complaints
• Multi-state compliance
• Litigation risk mitigation

Is certification available? ?
Yes. Participants can earn a Workplace/Internal Investigations Certification demonstrating professional competence.

Who should attend investigations training?
Ideal participants include:

• HR professionals
• Compliance officers
• Managers
• Supervisors
• Business owners

How does investigations training strengthen company culture?
It demonstrates commitment to:

• Fairness
• Accountability
• Safe workplaces
• Legal compliance

Can investigations training prevent lawsuits?
While no training eliminates risk, structured training significantly reduces exposure.

Why is refresher training important?
Laws evolve. Skills fade. Regular training maintains compliance readiness.

Can training be delivered on-site?
Yes. On-site training reduces travel costs and allows customization.

Are webinars available for focused topics?
Yes. Webinars cover specific areas such as FMLA abuse, harassment investigations, and employee relations inquiries.

How does certification improve professional credibility?
Certification demonstrates:

• Legal knowledge
• Procedural competence
• Risk management expertise

Is investigations training helpful for career advancement?
Yes. Investigation expertise is highly valued for HR leadership roles.

Why is investigations training considered essential for HR?
Investigations are one of HR's highest-risk responsibilities. Errors can create personal and organizational liability.

How does HR Training Center differentiate its programs?
Benefits include:

• Experienced instructors
• Practical, scenario-based instruction
• Legal compliance focus
• Industry-specific expertise

How do I enroll in a Workplace Investigations Training Program??
You can select from our Internal Investigations Certificate Program, Advanced Investigations Certification, or topic-specific webinars and register online or contact us to schedule on-site training.

Add Email For New Course Info, Dates, And News: